From the title and charming cover art by Santiago Caruso, I was hoping for plenty of "pagan terror" stories in this book. In fact there are only two stories that fall into that category, but they are the best in the anthology for my money. The first is 'Apple Pie and Sulphur' by Christopher Harman, a terrific writer who has distinguished himself many times before by incorporating Jamesian terror mechanisms and a love of the countryside into his own weird slant on the supernatural tale. His 'By Leaf and Thorn' stood head and shoulders above anything in the recent Strange Tales 4 from Tartarus Press and his offering here is also good, with a feeling of suffocating dread infusing a narrative about a group of everyblokes who patronize a cafe in some woods in the Lake District and live to regret it. The British landscape really comes alive in Harman's stories, full of a hypnotic, sometimes beautiful but often malignant life - it's no mere backdrop.
'The Statue' by Miriam Frey comes a close second, though it's hard to compare two stories that are so different in content, tone and execution. This is a brief but charming sylvan fantasy about a "man whom the trees loved" (as Algernon Blackwood might have put it) and I hope to see more of Frey in future. Robert Shearman's 'It Flows From the Mouth' also has a more rustic, garden setting than he usually employs (though the author has such a varied output it's hard to say exactly what Shearman "usually" does.) It's an odd but effective story based on a man's fraught relationship with his close friend which blossoms into terror via some sinister statuary in said friends' garden. Anyone who's read L.P. Hartley's 'The Two Vaynes' will know how much fear can be extracted from the subject of statues, and the theme is not wasted here, with a conversational prose style driving things along and preventing the whole thing from floating off into airy-fairy meaninglessness.
The rest of the stories have an urban or purely psychological theme. There are several big-hitter authors here: Conrad Williams provides 'Shaddertown', in which an older woman's trip underground on a guided tour of the tunnels under the old Manchester Guardian building provides her with a key to her troubled past. It's not one of his best stories but it's not bad. R.B. Russell is well represented by 'Night Porter', a fairly memorable piece of hotel-based nocturnal strangeness. Kaaron Warren is another writer who seems to crop up everywhere these days, and 'Death's Door Cafe' is a high concept story with a moral message - always hard to pull off, and not really my cup of tea. I really missed Joel Lane's presence - the collection is dedicated to him and he would certainly have been at home here.
Where the lesser-known authors are concerned, I think the best story was by Alison Moore - "Summerside" deals with the trauma of moving into a new home and discovering it's hidden side in a simple but vivid and effective way. Many of the other stories involve capital-C concepts and formats that attempt to innovate on the old cliches of horror fiction (Michael Wehunt's second-person riff on murder 'Onanon' is probably the best of these.) This is a good thing, though quite a few of these gambles don't really come off and the overall feel of the collection is a bit anaemic. The stories tend to cover ground that has already been well-trodden, especially in those old Year's Best Fantasy and Horror anthologies by Ellen Datlow and Terri Windling. Fiction that involves bizarre, unreasonable and inconclusive events just suddenly happening requires a certain amount of "oomph" and considerable beauty of style to avoid the feeling of laziness on the author's part (though I'm not suggesting any of these writers actually are lazy.)
Still, Shadows and Tall Trees does make a good palate-cleanser for those tired of run-of-the-mill pulpy fare. It's a refreshing change from all those collections dominated by steampunk and zombies. And I'm pretty sure that's what Kelly set out to do, so on that count it's definitely a success! And it's also very attractive for an affordable paperback, even by the high standards of publishers Undertow (formerly Nightshade) Press [ETA: Wrong! Skyhorse, not Nightshade, as it happens.]